Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Matt Ruby's avatar

I was sent your piece because I wrote a piece arguing for the “stupid” position you address here: https://substack.com/home/post/p-165632371

I appreciate where you’re coming from, but basically you seem to be arguing this: "It can't be perfect so it should feature a really bad thing and that's fine."

I disagree and think that argument is a dangerous/bad strategy electorally.

And re: this: "Sadly we’ve reached the societal point where instead we must pretend there is a moderate position between the two sides. One that is sympathetic to the plight of the undocumented while still criticizing the protests for not being perfect."

I fear this is what online tribalism does to people when the reality is MOST people are in the middle. Reaching out to moderates is a great idea if you like winning elections.

Sadly, this is all a gift to 47 and fulfills the MAGA fantasy that there is indeed a foreign invasion happening.

The question i ask w/ all this: Do you want to win or not? Because I’m confident waving foreign flags and a H@mas armband in front of torched cars is not the visual way to win national elections.

Myq Kaplan's avatar

Dear Sid,

This is an excellent, thoughtful piece.

Thank you for these lines, and also all the other ones:

“Now, in my opinion, every news outlet should be focused on why the Trump administration wants to spend over 100 million dollars to send tax payers to jail while violating the constitution and using the military to attack our own citizens.”

“If the protestors flew exclusively American flags, the media and powers that be would focus on another detail to excuse their lack of empathy for the cause.”

“Trying to tell protestors to be perfect is a waste of all of our time. Trying to tell protestors to hide a part of their identity is a waste of all of our time. Trying to find reasons for why you can watch a fascist torch our neighborhoods and not get involved is a waste of our time. So stop wasting our time and get involved.”

Thank you Sid!

Love

Myq

6 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?